What it tastes like

Flaky, crunchy peanut butter pieces. Eat it fairly quickly; the flakes get chewy as they sit in the soft serve.

How it compares

Blizzard Small price Small calories
Butterfinger $4.49 590
Reese’s $4.49 610
Heath $4.49 640
M&M’s $4.49 660

Reese’s is richer; Heath is the toffee alternative.

Ordering tips

  • One of the lightest year-round flavors: a Mini is about 350 calories.
  • Contains peanuts.

Every flavor and price is on the Blizzard menu, and our Blizzard rankings show where this one lands.

Butterfinger vs. Reese’s: which peanut butter Blizzard to get

The Butterfinger Blizzard is the lighter, flakier peanut butter option, and the Reese’s Blizzard is the richer, creamier one. Both cost about $4.49 for a Small, but Butterfinger has 590 calories and Reese’s 610.

Butterfinger pieces are crisp and layered, so they soften faster in the soft serve. Eat it within a few minutes for the best crunch. Reese’s cups hold their shape longer and taste more like a candy bar.

Butterfinger Blizzard by size

The Butterfinger Blizzard is one of the lighter year-round flavors at every size. A Mini is 350 calories, a Medium 800 and a Large 1,060.

The Medium costs about $5.29, 20 cents less than flavors like Oreo or Reese’s, so it is a quiet value pick for anyone who likes peanut butter.

Planning a full order? Add the Butterfinger Blizzard to our Dairy Queen calorie and price calculator with a side and a drink to see the total cost, calories and nutrition.

Frequently asked questions

It typically costs about $3.49 for a Mini, $4.49 for a Small, $5.29 for a Medium and $5.99 for a Large. Prices vary by location.
About 350 for a Mini, 590 for a Small, 800 for a Medium and 1,060 for a Large.
Yes. Butterfinger candy is made with peanut butter.

Reviewed by Ammar, Editor, The Queen Dairy Menu. Sources: Dairy Queen U.S. nutrition and allergen information, in-store menu boards and the DQ app. Prices are typical U.S. prices and vary by location; last checked November 2026.